-XXX is Celluloid Dimension’s naughty new column, exploring the wildest spectacles ever to heat up a screen-
Directed by Armand Weston
Written by Armand Weston
Starring:
- Jean Jennings as Cathy
- Fred J. Lincoln as Dr. Gabriel
- Day Jason as Susan
- Carole Holland (credited as Holly Landis) as Cathy’s Mother
- Steve Lincoln (credited as Roderick Usher) as Cathy’s Father
- Heather Ellis (credited as Ellen Hill) as Miss Caine
- Harding Harrison (credited as David Harrison) as Dr. Krausse
Release Date: January 7, 1974
Rating: 
Ah, the wonders of religious upbringing! Who would have thought that parental paranoia, religious brainwashing, and good old-fashioned Catholic holier-than-thou bullshit could send someone spiraling in precisely the opposite direction of spiritual redemption? Instead of finding God, Cathy (Jean Jannings) finds drugs, debauchery, and eventually a whole new world of S&M self-discovery! Such is the wonderfully fucked-up trajectory of this degenerate yet surprisingly thought-provoking coming-of-age porno flick, following a naive, virginal blonde whose religious fanatic parents have her committed to a sleazy mental institution after catching her experimenting with drugs with a friend.
Half psych-ward exploitation, half S&M gothic fever dream, Armand Weston’s grimy little excursion into sexual depravity takes Cathy on a decidedly unpleasant trip through the darkest recesses of human perversity. The full-time pornographer and one-time horror director initially seems determined to strip every last trace of eroticism from her ordeal, subjecting the unfortunate girl to a succession of bleak, degrading, and humiliating encounters. Trapped inside this miserable institution, Cathy comes face-to-face with an assortment of lunatics and sexual predators who look as though they’ve been summoned straight from the darkest corners of the Manson Family’s universe. The result is an increasingly vile parade of sexual violence, gang rape, and nymphomaniacal madness.
Jean Jannings, the legendary hardcore star, gives a remarkably vulnerable yet compelling performance, bringing such raw intensity to poor Cathy’s predicament that watching her get dragged through this nightmare becomes an increasingly uncomfortable experience. And considering she was only 17, there’s something almost alarmingly illicit about her youthful appearance in such a disreputable setting. The asylum sequences dutifully deliver the expected hardcore fare—money shots, close-ups, couple action, and solo action—but their presence hardly translates into anything resembling erotic gratification. Instead, Weston constructs an atmosphere of almost suffocating dread, turning what might ordinarily be conventional hardcore imagery into something distinctly nightmarish. The effect is made even more disconcerting by the bizarrely exhilarating musical accompaniment, whose almost cheerful disposition clashes spectacularly with the sexual violence unfolding onscreen.
New York-based director Armand Weston certainly knows a thing or two about keeping his audience on its toes. Just when we’ve had our fill of cold-blooded hardcore nastiness, he whisks us away with Cathy to an imposing, sprawling mansion that looks like it could be hiding more monsters than human inhabitants. And what a welcoming committee awaits her! Enter Fred J. Lincoln, whom exploitation aficionados will undoubtedly remember as one of the particularly unsavory characters from The Last House on the Left. But forget the kindly doctor routine: this gentleman has a considerably kinkier agenda. Before long, Cathy discovers that her supposed benefactor is actually a sadomasochistic priest with some rather unconventional ideas about spiritual enlightenment.
This is the picture’s most peculiar transformation: the unerotic turns intoxicatingly erotic, the grotesque acquires an unexpected beauty, and Weston’s grimy sex film begins to resemble a perverse fairy tale of liberation. Cathy appears to shed the religious and moral shackles that once defined her, embracing the instincts her upbringing taught her to suppress. But the real surprise is the allegorical charge beneath all this XXX excess—a troubling, fascinating idea wrapped in an awful lot of dirty business.
The more you examine the narrative undercurrents of The Defiance of Good, the more disturbing its central parallels become. Religious indoctrination begins to resemble the very perversion it so desperately seeks to eradicate, exposing a rather ugly irony beneath all that moral posturing. Weston drives the point home through an astonishingly Gothic visual landscape: claustrophobic corridors, cavernous interiors, Expressionist shadows, and an imposing house that seems to have a personality—and a wicked agenda—of its own. It’s hard not to recognize the horror filmmaker lurking beneath the pornographer. In fact, you might find yourself thinking: The Nesting wasn’t born out of nowhere!
